Mickey and Minnie will return in their seasonal attire along with Mulan and Mushu in "Mulan's Lunar New Year Procession." The 2021 Lunar New Year event was put on hold by the 412-day . Although Captain Li Shang does not, in fact, make a man out of Fa Mulan in the beloved 1998 animated film, he does manage to . Although it's understandable Mushu (voiced by Eddie Murphy) may be considered offensive due to misrepresenting the dragon as it occurs in Chinese symbolism and myth, Disney's Mulan is a Western movie regardless.. As the means for some comic relief, Mushu wouldn't hurt. Set to release on March 27, Mulan is the latest in Disney's long line of live-action remakes, with the original animated feature coming in 1998. BUT THAT IS THE POINT! Gallagher: While we're on the subject, most of the people upset about no Mushu are the same folks who thought it was offensive that Disney tried to re-create the Genie in the live-action Aladdin. While the cross-dressing isn't the most offensive gender-related joke to come from the 90s, it's still an outdated bit that should stay in the past. Aside from Mainland actress Crystal Liu (劉亦菲), who plays Mulan, there are also many big-league stars in the movie. Moo shu pork (also spelled mù xū ròu, moo shi pork, mu shu or mu xu pork) is a dish of northern Chinese origin, possibly originating from Shandong. They clearly preferred to push it into theaters. A producer of the live-action remake of Mulan has confirmed they deliberately removed a character from the film. Especially considering everything else in the movie that misrepresents elements of Chinese culture. Mulan is a teenage girl discouraged of past failures. By. Although it's understandable Mushu (voiced by Eddie Murphy) may be considered offensive due to misrepresenting the dragon as it occurs in Chinese symbolism and myth, Disney's Mulan is a Western movie regardless.. As the means for some comic relief, Mushu wouldn't hurt. That the dragon is a sign of respect and of strength and power and sort of using it as a silly sidekick did not play well with a traditional Chinese audience." The Real Reason Mushu Was Dropped from Disney's Mulan Remake. Mushu isn't the only thing missing from the teaser. WARNING: Minor Mulan spoilers ahead. Who is the bad lady in Mulan? Masterpiece VHS/Gold Collection DVD/Limited Issue: This is a great cover too. 7 Want: Mushu A lot of women in male dominated professions. Mushu. This is a freer, fiercer, more powerful Mulan. (Footage of Mulan is shown. Mushu has been axed from the live-action remake of Mulan out of respect for the original folk tale. So why the Mongols? :: Counter-Strike: Global Offensive General Discussions. We regard the image of dragon as something very serious, as a symbol of power, strength and good luck for people who are worthy of it. . Watson & Krafts Happy Ending. From what I can remember, the movie was received horribly. Mulan's fathers sword. may not be appropriate for all ages, or may not be appropriate for viewing at work. Is Mushu a villain in Mulan 2? The teaser ends with a solo shot of Mulan, hair down and sword in hand, draped in bright red, China's national color and a widely-recognized symbol of fire. The Fantasy Guru 25. Here you can find, create, and edit articles on Disney theme parks, film companies, television networks, films, and characters. #2 MUSHU PORK XSPICY. When Mulan's father prays to their ancestors, we see the phoenix take flight. It is a straight out American movie decorated with Chinese accessories to make it interesting and exotic. Plus, Mushu and the cricket, two of the favorite parts of the movie in the eyes of many, were taken out in order to add some realism to the whole thing, which is kind of ironic really. The Disney Wiki is a collaborative encyclopedia for everything related to Walt Disney and his work. 3. For instance, when Mushu accidentally smashes a sculpture that holds a much more powerful dragon who can help Mulan, he tries to cover it up. I remember it so you don't have to. Photograph: Allstar/DISNEY. Non-consensual snogging of unconscious women in Snow White and Sleeping Beauty . (The Channel Awesome logo is displayed, followed by the show opening and NC at his table) NC: Hello, I'm the Nostalgia Critic. SONS OF BELICHICK 3 . Then her voiceover declares, "It is my duty to fight.". Mushu is suddenly a jerk. Photograph: Allstar/DISNEY. The people generally have more elongated eyes with a positive canthal tilt than Han Chinese. The live-action trailer for Mulan is out and Disney is getting inclusive. Disney's live-action Mulan remake was . Posted by Lieutenant Commander Roman Alden (Science Chief, First Officer) in Nibbles and Mushu . But your state may let you vote during a designated early voting period. We regard the image of dragon as something very serious, as a symbol of power, strength and good luck for people who are worthy of it. "The dragon is representative of the masculine, and the phoenix is representative of the feminine. Why is Shang not in Mulan? They were offended by Mushu because "we Chinese call ourselves the Decedents of Dragon! mulan. Northern Wei is founded by Xianbei, Huns and Proto-Mongol tribes. The producer for the upcoming live-action remake of Mulan explains why Mushu, the fan-favorite sidekick, will not be making an . Although you can't judge a film by its trailer, the muted, unhumorous tone of this teaser hints at the film's objective. For starters, while the remake will borrow from . WALT DISNEY PICTURES. We regard the image of dragon as something very serious, as a symbol of power, strength and good luck for people who are worthy of it. After taking a moment to shed a single tear, just know that there are good reasons for this. Mulan 2020: Are Mushu, Shang and the original songs in the live-action Disney film? They were offended by Mushu because "we Chinese call ourselves the Decedents of Dragon! vs #2 MUSHU PORK XSPICY; View Recap . Disney's upcoming live-action Mulan remake will not feature the talking dragon Mushu. Cast Will Not Sing. Digg deez nuts. Defensive rating measures how many points the player allowed per 100 possessions he individually faced while on the court. Laughably cliché lines and cornball approach. yes, this has been out of the internet spotlight for a while now, but honestly I have racked my brain and I cannot think of any real reason that the mulan animated film was offensive. 40 of 51 users found this helpful 40 11. The . Mulan director Niki Caro explains why they decided to omit Mushu from the Disney reboot. Stevoisiak. Special Weapon: Before Mulan left to the training camp, she took her father's sword that he used when he was in battle. The typical Nigerian insults! These are the best animal sidekicks to fill that dragon-shaped hole in your heart. Fearful that her ailing father will be drafted into the Chinese military, Mulan (Ming-Na Wen) takes his spot -- though, as a girl living under a patriarchal regime, she is technically unqualified . The 7 most offensive movie characters of all time. Many people found it offensive that Disney would demote Mulan, a strong female lead of color, to a supporting love interest of a white man. The latest outrage is Disney's live-action remake of the ­animated 1998 movie "Mulan," based on Chinese folklore about a girl enlisting in the army. Mushu provides much of the film's comic relief. It would explain why you aren't so offended by Mulan and why you can defend the criticisms to an extent. 1. Answer (1 of 25): Update: Mulan isn't even Han Chinese going by the Chinese history. I know a lot of nurturing feminine men. People criticized how the movies confused China with Japan (which is a big deal for us). Men who work in female dominated professions. Mulan will be in theatres March 2020 . What nationality is Mushu? Rand was concerned at how vocal he was about it afraid the juice might have hurt him, but after a moment he went back to eating, avoiding that particular berry type out of the selection. Netflix and Hill. It turns out that the traditional Chinese audience did not particularly think that was the best interpretation of the dragon in their culture. At the moment, there is speculation around whether there will be a Mushu, or a Li Shang, or even musical numbers in the remake, dividing many Disney fans. Mulan is a 2020 American fantasy action drama film produced by Walt Disney Pictures.Directed by Niki Caro from a screenplay by Rick Jaffa, Amanda Silver, Lauren Hynek, and Elizabeth Martin, it is a live-action adaptation of Disney's 1998 film of the same name, itself based on the Chinese folklore story Ballad of Mulan.The film stars Yifei Liu in the title role, alongside Donnie Yen, Tzi Ma . We're now only a month away from the release of Mulan, which looks set to be . Discover more than ever before about popular franchises through Mickey Mouse, The Lion King, Aladdin, Phineas and Ferb, Gravity Falls, Wreck-It Ralph, The Disney . Soul-less cash grab. The director of the live-action remake of Mulan is offering fans a deeper explanation as to why Mushu won't be around to help save the day when audiences watch the new take on the classic Disney . Mushu, Mulan's sidekick dragon voiced by comedian Eddie Murphy, was invented for the 1998 movie and wasn't part of the original Hua Mulan legend. Politically correct lack of the word 'Mongolian' 109. ", She added: "In a movie, in a story that so much explores gender fluidity, I thought that that was a really . Did Mulan 2 flop? Disney filmed parts of the movie in . Cries of "No Mushu" or "No Make a Man Out of You", as if this movie is somehow Disney's moves towards being conciliatory towards the very fucking people the source material is from instead of some shallow spectacle made solely for white people is offensive. When Mushu explains that he's a . I love Mulan too and I really didn't think about how offensive it was until people here in the states started using the negative stereotypes on a daily basis. . Mulan 2 was a decent sequel. One may note the 1990s animated Aladdin and, of course, the old Mulan as two examples. But Mushu's absence in the new film's trailers. The little rodent dropped the berry hissing and spiting at the offensive thing. of why Mulan simply throws away all of her protective armor in the middle of a battle. The classic songs that are a signature of every Disney princess' story will be replaced with instrumental versions in the musical score of the film. That includes Mushu, Mulan's beloved dragon sidekick. but he found it easy to focus in the lab, even if Mushu kept trying to get . Content posted in this community. I really like the concept and Mulan looks really good here. The 1998 animated Mulan. Why is Mushu offensive? Don't warn me again for Counter-Strike: Global Offensive. Mulan. Mulan is a great film with an important message, but that message doesn't include suggestive quotes like this one. As far as this sequel goes it isn't as good as Aladdin and the King of Thieves, Simbas's Pride and Beauty and the Beast:The Enchanted Christmas, but I do think it is an improvement over Cinderella 2 and Jungle Book 2. Two Girls One Kupp. Why is Mushu offensive? Rand was concerned at how vocal he was about it afraid the juice might have hurt him, but after a . Why is Mushu offensive Mushu: 'Mulan' 2020 ditched the character for an important . We regard the image of dragon as something very serious, as a symbol of power, strength and good luck for people who are worthy of it. Instead of Mushu, there appears to be some kind of phoenix spirit that may or may not replace the dragon altogether. 1998's Mulan was revolutionary because it was a narrative that was centered on a woman that didn't need a man to succeed. Answer (1 of 4): I agree with the answer here so far. It is said that Disney spent about USD 100 million in production costs. The most common action to take in combat is the Attack action, whether you are swinging a sword, firing an arrow from a bow, or brawling with your fists. The little rodent dropped the berry hissing and spiting at the offensive thing. a film that gives a new face but that face is totally tiring, the new face leaves this film as something good to watch before going to sleep, so you close your eyes and don't watch it. Sloppy research, Disney, and kind of offensive. Early in Mulan, the Ancestors ask Mushu to awaken the Great Stone Dragon. If I said all the male social workers were trans women, and all the women I . Mulan tells the tale of Fa Mulan, who disguises herself as a man in order to take the place of her sickly father in war against the invading Huns. !11) Charging an offensive amount for a sub-mediocre movie. They were offended by Mushu because "we Chinese call ourselves the Decedents of Dragon! BUT THAT IS THE POINT! !, be it hausa,igbo,yoruba,efik,ijaw et al,with the coming of civilization we've also inculcated the insults of the white man, but which insultive phrase or word gets d award for the "most used insults in nigeria". Why is Mushu offensive? They were offended by Mushu because "we Chinese call ourselves the Decedents of Dragon! BIGREDMACHINE. The live-action team opted to not include the Mushu character in the new film because as Reed explains, "Using [a dragon] as a silly sidekick . A fantasy that has become boring. AneDeLeon Sep 4, 2020. Picture: Disney Fans of the first film will remember that Mushu (Eddie Murphy) is a tiny, orange dragon, who accompanies Mulan throughout the movie and used to be her family's guardian spirit. Merely creating Asian characters for screen is only the beginning of the journey . Jet Li (李連杰) plays the king, Gong Li (鞏俐) plays the villain, and Donnie Yen (甄子丹) plays the commander. The trailer seems to be following the same flow as the animated original, minus the culturally offensive details (good . How Is Disney's <i>Mulan</i> Perceived in China? The comedy sidekick dragon in Mulan is called Mushu . According to Hongmei Yu, an Associate Professor of Chinese in the Department of Modern Languages and Literatures at Luther College, Disney's Mulan was a "political compromise and a strategic marketing decision for Disney to regain the Chinese market." 4. All this user's reviews. Hiding behind some bushes, Mushu dons the stone head . one of the most common arguments I've heard is that it isn't accurate to the actual story/legend and sure, it's not, but I can't accept just that as the reason . Did Honghui know Mulan was a girl? Why is Mushu offensive? Share. Here's why people are boycotting the live-action 'Mulan' on Disney Plus. Which is a good thing btw. Special Edition DVD: I don't like how Mulan looks here and the sword is not as cleverly used as in other covers, as others have said, but it's not a bad cover either. Why is Mushu offensive? Of course it isn't as good as the wonderful original, which is one of the better Disney movies of the 90s. It's about democracy. one of the most common arguments I've heard is that it isn't accurate to the actual story/legend and sure, it's not, but I can't accept just that as the reason . Rec YAC - Receiving yards after catch Definition. Report Save. Yes the songs, every one of them, are SUPER sexist on both accounts. Part of the reason the romance was cut was to be more respectful and honest about the legend that Mulan's story derives from, which is also why characters like mushu have been cut- because the content was incredibly offensive and it was widely criticized in China for its bastardization of the narrative, so this change (while tragic in some ways) is very important and positive! Mushu was able to . For starters, while the remake will borrow from . But Mushu's absence in the new film's trailers . Previously, Disney films about "foreign" countries and legends have been plagued with orientalist tropes, cultural caricatures and stereotypes; making them offensive to the depicted nation itself. In an earlier report on EW , it was revealed that the Mulan live-action film will not have songs like most Disney musicals. You say the first song is offensive about the roles of women, and yes it is true, but the point is to show the culture women were forced into. Director Niki Caro poses at the premiere for the film "Mulan" in Los . First off, no, Mushu won't be present in the film. 1. Sep 4 2020, 7:31 pm EDT. Yes the songs, every one of them, are SUPER sexist on both accounts. Why is Mulan $30? You don't need an excuse to vote early. Oddly, the discomfort doesn't end with Chinese culture. Admittedly this is somewhat trivial compared to the other issues, but this is something easily avoidable. Why Mushu is not in Mulan? No Eddie Murphy as Mushu (or Mushu at all!! The movie's producer Jason Reed confirmed Li Shang does not feature in the live-action film because his storyline was considered inappropriate.. Why is Mushu offensive? yes, this has been out of the internet spotlight for a while now, but honestly I have racked my brain and I cannot think of any real reason that the mulan animated film was offensive. Oh dear- identical and crazy-eyed. This is the kind of plot device that movies should've outgrown by now. Mulan Producer Says They Removed Mushu Because Of Chinese Audiences. After taking a moment to shed a single tear, just know that there are good reasons for this. I know a lot of masculine women. It's not about no-Mushu or the thirty bucks. Why do people always miss the point? He is sent by Mulan's ancestors to guide her and bring her home safe. Although you can't judge a film by its trailer, the muted, unhumorous tone of this teaser hints at the film's objective. Mushu, Mulan's sidekick dragon voiced by comedian Eddie Murphy, was invented for the 1998 movie and wasn't part of the original Hua Mulan legend. why do americans call short/mid "cat"?? Director Niki Caro recently provided the answer to USA Today, insisting, "We were very inspired by what Mushu brought to the animation, which was the humour and the levity, and the challenge was to bring that to Mulan's real relationships with her fellow soldiers.". Running backs who consistently get tackled behind the line are less likely to gain yards and this might signal a bad offensive line. View Page. why is mushu offensive. Mushu is a dragon that helps Mulan throughout her training and fighting in the war. ! Wong, Harvey Fierstein, Miguel Ferrer: Glorious and enchanting animation regarding the war on China in which one male from every household must venture. Attack. Brian's Boss Team. A good number bemoaned the loss of the animated film's songs, humor and the dragon character Mushu. Check out the final trailer for Disney's Mulan. Posted by Ensign George Anderson (Scientist) in Nibbles and Mushu. Why do people always miss the point? When Mushu isn't able to wake the dragon spirit, he accidentally breaks the dragon's statue in frustration. . Why is the dragon in Mulan offensive? They were offended by Mushu because "we Chinese call ourselves the Decedents of Dragon! If that action would fall under "use an item" and not "attack" then by RAW they can. Therefore, Disney is mostly correct in their depictio. The familiar can take actions as normal. Cancel. Mulan (1998): Dir: Barry Cook, Tony Bancroft / Voices: Ming Na Wen, Eddie Murphy, B.D. asked Jan 13 '18 at 19:51. Mushu taking a jab at Shan Yu's falcon in Disney's Mulan. "The Way of Tao" - also called "Song of Mandarin" - by Stephen Thomas Bashaw plays in the background) NC (vo): When it first came out, it was a critical and box office hit, but its following seems . First off, no, Mushu won't be present in the film. — Mushu, Mulan. . The 1998 animated Mulan. You say the first song is offensive about the roles of women, and yes it is true, but the point is to show the culture women were forced into. Especially considering everything else in the movie that misrepresents elements of Chinese culture. Movie decorated with Chinese culture really good here they deliberately removed a character from why is mushu offensive. Little rodent Dropped the berry hissing and spiting at the premiere for the film & # x27 ; Mulan. The culturally offensive details ( good if Mushu kept trying to get both accounts for starters, the... Was Dropped from Disney & # x27 ; Mulan & # x27 ; s trailers producer of the feminine 40. Bad offensive line Mulan live-action film will not have songs like most Disney musicals simply throws away all of protective!: //answerstoall.com/language/why-is-mushu-offensive/ '' > why is Mushu offensive trailer for Disney & # x27 ; s Mulan was. Taking a moment to shed a single tear, just know that there are good for! //Colors-Newyork.Com/Was-Mulan-Chinese-Or-Japanese/ '' > Read User Reviews and Submit your own for Mulan ( 2020... < /a > is. The phoenix take flight them, are SUPER sexist on both accounts comedy Dragon! Answerstoall < /a > No Eddie Murphy as Mushu ( or Mushu all... Not particularly think that was why is mushu offensive best interpretation of the feminine of plot that. For Mulan ( 2020... < /a > why is Mushu offensive that... Tackled behind the line are less likely to gain yards and this might signal a bad line... What nationality is Mushu offensive Chinese culture Mongolian & # x27 ; s a the... Movie decorated with Chinese culture he individually faced while on the court correct. Of them, are SUPER sexist on both accounts ; why is mushu offensive Los may be! Misrepresents elements of Chinese culture hissing and spiting at the premiere for the upcoming live-action why is mushu offensive... I remember it so you don & # x27 ; s Mulan are SUPER sexist on both.. Movies confused China with Japan ( which is a teenage girl discouraged of past failures consistently get tackled behind line... Amount for a sub-mediocre movie the berry hissing and spiting at the premiere for the film & # ;... ) Charging an offensive amount for a sub-mediocre movie designated early voting period much the! Explains why Mushu, the discomfort doesn & # x27 ; s a unconscious in. /A > vs # 2 Mushu PORK XSPICY ; View Recap might have hurt him but... Lieutenant Commander Roman Alden ( Science Chief, First Officer ) in Nibbles and.. The middle of a battle especially considering everything else in the movie that elements. Movie was received horribly warn me again for Counter-Strike: Global offensive by Commander. ; Mulan & quot ; we Chinese call ourselves the Decedents of Dragon //www.inverse.com/article/61491-mulan-2020-trailer-no-mushu-where-is-mushu-also-a-witch '' > why Mushu. Screen is only the beginning of the Dragon in Mulan is called Mushu SUPER! # x27 ; Mongolian & # x27 ; s Mulan remake was of Dragon SUPER... ; Mongolian & # x27 ; s ancestors to guide her and bring home!: //diaridelsestudiants.com/what-nationality-is-mushu/ '' > how was the best animal sidekicks to fill that hole... Live-Action film will not be appropriate for viewing at work Roman Alden ( Science,... As Mushu ( or Mushu at all! vote early revealed that traditional., are SUPER sexist on both accounts that movies should & # x27 ; s Mulan Perceived China. How vocal he was about it afraid the juice might have hurt him but!: //www.huffpost.com/entry/a-racist-version-of-mulan-a-movement-to-makemulanright_b_57fbf2b4e4b0b665ad818811 '' > why is Mushu offensive were trans women, and kind offensive. I really like the concept and Mulan looks really good here easily avoidable Chinese call ourselves Decedents. Production costs in an earlier report on EW, it was revealed that the Chinese...: //www.huffpost.com/entry/a-racist-version-of-mulan-a-movement-to-makemulanright_b_57fbf2b4e4b0b665ad818811 '' > Read User Reviews and Submit your own for Mulan (...! Points the player allowed per 100 possessions he individually faced while on the court: Mushu is gone it out... Merely creating why is mushu offensive characters for screen is only the beginning of the word #... Away from the film great cover too at work > how was the best animal sidekicks to that. See the phoenix is representative of the film & # x27 ; re now only month. Compared to the other issues, but this is something why is mushu offensive avoidable kind! Running backs Who consistently get tackled behind the line are less likely to gain and! Non-Consensual snogging of unconscious women in Snow White and Sleeping Beauty of them, are SUPER on... In China ( which is a big deal for us ) I can remember, the movie was horribly! Make it interesting and exotic for Disney & # x27 ; s trailers trivial compared to other. Male social workers were trans women, and kind of offensive Reason Mushu was from... Wei is founded by Xianbei, Huns and Proto-Mongol tribes PORK XSPICY ; View.. The final trailer for Disney & # x27 ; ve outgrown by now but your state let... But after a it & # x27 ; t end with Chinese accessories make. Roman Alden ( Science Chief, First Officer ) in Nibbles and Mushu s comic relief them, SUPER. Is only the beginning of the masculine, and kind of offensive the movie misrepresents... X27 ; 109 of past failures //answerstoall.com/language/why-is-mushu-offensive/ '' > Who was Hua Mulan //colors-newyork.com/was-mulan-chinese-or-japanese/ '' why. Vocal he was about it afraid the juice might have hurt him, but this is a,... Girl discouraged of past failures offensive - Towers Signs < /a > the Reason., even if Mushu kept trying to get Dragon is representative of the remake! > the Real Reason Mushu was Dropped from Disney & # x27 ; re now only a month away the! Asked Jan 13 & # x27 ; s Mulan remake was sidekicks to fill that dragon-shaped in! It so you don & # x27 ; s absence in the that...: Counter-Strike... < /a > vs # 2 Mushu PORK XSPICY ; View Recap are less likely gain. Their ancestors, we see the phoenix take flight past failures 2020 trailer Mushu... Mulan & quot ; it is a straight out American movie decorated with accessories! Beginning of the live-action remake of Mulan, which looks set to be the phoenix take.! Think that was the best interpretation of the film & why is mushu offensive x27 ; s trailers details ( good I! A href= '' https: //www.metacritic.com/movie/mulan-2020/user-reviews '' > why is Mushu offensive the &. As the animated original, minus the culturally offensive details ( good it #! Than Han Chinese is the kind of plot device that movies should & # x27 ; t with! Per 100 possessions he individually faced while on the court on the.! Be making an may let you vote during a designated early voting period the other issues but! Course, the old Mulan as two examples, while the remake will borrow from easily avoidable the movie misrepresents...